I was so absorbed by the movie that I didn't notice you coming in.

Status
Not open for further replies.
9

99bottles

Banned
Joined
Apr 11, 2018
Member Type
Interested in Language
Native Language
Greek
Home Country
Greece
Current Location
Greece
I found that sentence on the Idioms site.

idioms.thefreedictionary.com

absorbed by

Definition of absorbed by in the Idioms Dictionary by The Free Dictionary
idioms.thefreedictionary.com idioms.thefreedictionary.com

The thing is, in all other online dictionaries, the passive form of that verb (when the meaning is to hold someone's interest) is absorbed in. Is by also acceptable? Why is this the only dictionary that mentions this structure?
 
I prefer "absorbed in something", which is like saying one is engrossed in (not by) an activity.
 
I have no way of knowing why it's only in that dictionary. Your guess is as good as mine.

I agree with tedmc.
 
99bottles said:
in all other online dictionaries, the passive form of that verb (when the meaning is to hold someone's interest) is absorbed in.
Click to expand...
In a couple of the dictionaries I looked at, absorbed (followed by in) is given as an adjective.

With by, we have the passive of the verb absorb.
 
5jj said:
In a couple of the dictionaries I looked at, absorbed (followed by in) is given as an adjective.

With by, we have the passive of the verb absorb.
Click to expand...
So absorbed by sounds like he was in the process of being absorbed, whereas absorbed in means his attention was already elsewhere. Did I get it right?
 
I agree with 5jj. The use of by shows that the writer is thinking of absorbed as a passive verb rather than an adjective.

99bottles said:
So absorbed by sounds like he was in the process of being absorbed
Click to expand...

Not in the process, no. The past tense was shows that the process was already complete by this point.
 
jutfrank said:
I agree with 5jj. The use of by shows that the writer is thinking of absorbed as a passive verb rather than an adjective.



Not in the process, no. The past tense was shows that the process was already complete by this point.
Click to expand...
But if the whole story is written in the past tense, the past tense does not necessarily show that the process was complete at this point.
 
If the process were still underway, it would say was being absorbed, right? The past simple gives the sense of completion.

Anyway, I suggest you just forget about this example. My feeling is that the writer was trying to use absorbed as an adjective (evidenced by the degree modifier so) and that they should therefore have used in instead.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5jj
jutfrank said:
If the process were still underway, it would say was being absorbed, right? The past simple gives the sense of completion.

Anyway, I suggest you just forget about this example. My feeling is that the writer was trying to use absorbed as an adjective (evidenced by the degree modifier so) and that they should therefore have used in instead.
Click to expand...
So, can I use either by or in? Is there a difference in meaning?
 
99bottles said:
So, can I use either by or in? Is there a difference in meaning?
Click to expand...

I thought we'd already outlined the difference in meaning. With by, the speaker is thinking of absorbed as a passive verb—what we're calling a completed process. With in, absorbed is better understood as a descriptive state.
 
jutfrank said:
So absorbed by sounds like he was in the process of being absorbed, whereas absorbed in means his attention was already elsewhere. Did I get it right?
Click to expand...
Tarheel, you liked that post. Does that mean you agree?
 
That's what that means, yes.
😊
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

M
Diary - When my friend Jenny was a child
Replies
11
Views
84
Maybo
M
W
And there was another benefit to/of the group setting ...
Replies
0
Views
68
WilliamTaft
W
S
I was taught to read in a mechanical way...
Replies
1
Views
91
Fen
F
E
she's going to miss the game she was/has been driving to
Replies
2
Views
91
EngLearner
E
V
When I was eating/While I was eating
Replies
1
Views
83
emsr2d2
emsr2d2
Back
Top