Which one can be a Phrasal Verb?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Nikolaeff

New member
Joined
Feb 19, 2022
Member Type
English Teacher
Native Language
Russian
Home Country
Russian Federation
Current Location
Russian Federation
Which one can be regarded as a Phrasal Verb and why?

We’ve got two sentences:

  1. I take care of plants and flowers.
  2. I go for a stroll with animals.
In the first sentence “take care of sth” I see as a phrasal verb. A friend of mine says that it’s not a phrasal verb, it’s just a phrase. She adds that “go for sth” is the only phrasal verb in this case.

Which of the two variants can be seen as the usage of a phrasal verb?
 
Two things. One, grammar terms are not proper nouns. Two, I don't know why "take care of" is not a phrasal verb. (Maybe somebody will explain that.)

Plants and flowers are not two different things. (I suppose "I go for a stroll with animals" makes sense in the right context, but it's hard to imagine what that might be.)
 
I also don’t understand why “take care of” can’t be a phrasal verb… it also contains of a verb and a preposition.
 
It consist of a verb and a noun and a preposition/adverb/particle.

There is no universally accepted definition of 'phrasal verb', but 'noun' does not appear in most definitions.
 
Well, "care" can be a noun or a verb. And "take care of" has a meaning that the words don't have individually.
 
I also don’t understand why “take care of” can’t be a phrasal verb… it also contains of a verb and a preposition.
Does the preposition modify the meaning in the way that give up smoking has a meaning that the individual words' dictionary definitions will not give you. Verb + preposition that does not modify the meaning doesn't fit the definition of phrasal verb for many as the prepositions is doing what prepositions do- connect.
 
Are they delexical structures?

I don't like or use that term but yes, you can certainly think of take as delexical there. Is there a reason you need a label for these verb phrases? Or are you just trying to work out what is normally meant by the term 'phrasal verb'?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5jj
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top